Adventures in Group Exercise Classes: Yoga-Part 1

The practice of yoga dates back centuries ago as a religious tradition of meditation. The yoga that we come to think of today is a revised form of these earlier principles. Most would agree that yoga as it was originally practiced is no longer practiced as such. Western yoga as we know it has become more focused on “asanas” or varying sustained postures as a form of exercise. Along with exercise, many yoga practices also focus on meditation and breathing as a form of relaxation. There have been many research studies that have shown the benefits of yoga for its relaxation and meditative purposes. For instances, a study in 2010 by the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine showed that regular yoga practice has shown to increase brain GABA levels more than walking and jogging. An increase in brain GABA levels has been shown to elevate mood and decrease anxiety. Because of some of these research articles, I have always encouraged my patients at Performance Spine and Sports Medicine in Newtown to engage in gentle yoga, of course within their limitations. However, yoga has come under the gun recently for possibly creating more harm than good.

The New York Times recently posted an article titled “How Yoga Can Wreck your Body”. Being a physical therapist and a yoga enthusiast, this automatically intrigued me. The article tells the story of a yoga “guru” who spent years studying in India with yoga legends and was a teacher in New York. Eventually, the teacher had to have major spinal surgery as, what he believes, was a result of years of yoga. The author also tells some other unfortunate stories of people who have been thought to have sustained serious life threatening injuries from yoga. 

I appreciated the fact that this NY times columnist pointed out some of the dangers of yoga and that it is not for everyone, but I think it tells a story more about the danger of doing ANYTHING to the extreme. There is no way of knowing whether or not this yoga teacher’s back injury was due to his yoga practice, and the article lacked strong research to support that all yoga is bad.

In fear of an abandonment of yoga altogether because of this article, I will offer some general recommendations and clear up some common misconceptions on my next “Adventures in Group Exercise Class”. I will explore a yoga class at my local gym and provide my recommendations regarding the safety of this ancient practice. In the meantime, feel free to leave some comments regarding your thoughts on the NY Times article. Do you think Yoga is dangerous??

Adventures in Group Exercise Classes: Yoga-Part 2

Adventure 1: Zumba